difference between litho and gravure printingdifference between litho and gravure printing

Im always searching for a deep understanding of the reasons why projects are moving away from offset printing. Among respondents to the most recent Catalog Age Benchmark Report on Print and Production (October 2000 issue), 83% printed their catalogs using offset lithography; 10% used rotogravure printing, and 6% used both. These will be very briefly discussed later. Touts Droits Rservs, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithography, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photogravure. But because the plates need replacing after about 1 million-2 million impressions, offset printing requires additional plates for longer runs. Water based, uv based , and alcohol based inks are used. The printer operator can control the ink flow, which means there are fewer wasted prints that dont provide enough contrast within the images. You can find more information on the page dedicated to offset printing. (Direct-to-cylinder for gravure was available before CTP for offset because the gravure etching process was already computer-driven.). Applied to the image carrier and exposed to light, the colloid forms an continuous, insoluble coating. The process can be used to print on paper, cardboard, plastic, or other materials, but these have to have a flat surface. The prices of both plates and cylinders are going down, making gravure more competitive in short runs and offset more cost-efficient in long runs. Cost analysis will show that the point at which offset becomes less cost-efficient and gravure more economical for catalogs 48 pages and smaller is around 1.25 million-1.5 million catalogs, with qualifications such as page size, number of versions, and if the book uses the same paper throughout or a better grade of paper stock for the cover or outer wrap. Gloss and silk coated-$- easily available most used so mills make tons and tons- least expensive In the end, the differences between gravure and offset are becoming less marked. Put thin aluminum foil completely over the stamp. The process of printing a lithograph on a hard, flat surface; originally the printing surface was a flat piece of stone that was etched with acid to form a surface that would selectively transfer ink to the paper; the stone has now been replaced, in general, with a metal plate. Digital images can also be printed using any of the other printing technologies. That inked image is subsequently transferred (or offset) from the plate to a rubber blanket and then to the printing surface. Virtually all collectors know the words line engraving, offset, gravure and other printing terms, but thats frequently where the understanding of how stamps are printed ends. Thanks for sharing , What digital card printers are best for printing PVC business cards only, from scanned original paper cards? A computer reads the color bars and adjusts the ink supply to maintain the color. Non-printing areas are recessed below the level of the inking rollers and therefore are not coated with ink. For many modern stamps, more than one printing type may be used on a single stamp. Gravure color is generally deeper and richer than offset, in part because you can apply more ink to an area than with offset. Copy assembly consists of bringing all original work (text, pictures, and illustrations) together and preparing photographic images. Get the Ecommerce, Marketing & Operations info you need when you need it. Lithograph vs Print. I cant find a good translation and dont know what type of it. APS StampStores first month transition to HipStamp a huge success! The ink is then passed to the substrate from the cells. Among the printing industrys most significant breakthroughs of the past 10 years is the elimination of film, thanks to the direct-to-plate or computer-to-plate (CTP) systems. Not all are true printing types, as they describe characteristics or inks. As noted above, usinghalftone photography achieves the the illusion of intermediate tones for letterpress, lithography, lateral dot gravure, and screen printing. Direct printing (Figure 1) refers to the application of ink by direct contact between printing surface and substrate (paper, plastic or whatever youre printing stamps on). In this way, aligning ink colors is more challenging with offset printing than with gravure. Copying entire pages is, however, not allowed. There are other methods of image carrier preparation, including manual, mechanical, electrochemical, electronic, and electrostatic. The colloid is formed when the finely divided bichromate and the collodion are mixed. Gravure printing engraves your design into metal cylinders. Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License; additional terms may apply.See Wiktionary Terms of Use for details. The picture below shows such a much larger web press. Each process uses avariety of chemicals, depending on the operation involved. Computer systems are equipped with both optical character recognition and photographic image scanners and digitizers so that pre-typed material and photographic images are easilyincorporated into the document being composed. Can you suggest me a way to get it done with low capital exp. Sign in to download full-size image Figure 2.24. Gravure can print on coated supercalendered paper that is lighter than 28 lb. TG/RG. Quick printers and copy shops print digitally on presses from vendors like Xerox, HP, Canon, and Konica Minolta. Maybe I should save up a lot for that because I can imagine that it would cost more than more traditional printing methods. Webis that lithograph is a printed image produced by lithography; an image produced by etching the image onto a flat surface, then copying the etched surface by applying ink (or the equivalent) to it and pressing another material against it while gravure is (arts|printing) a type of intaglio printing process, in which an image is engraved onto a Hi, I was looking for it for a long time. A 1975 U.S. development in siderography (the practice of transferring images from die to plate) is to transfer designs from a roll directly to a cylinder, or sleeve, instead of transferring them to a flat plate and bending it for rotary press use (Figures 14, 15). Details of the design (Figure 7) are frequently transferred to the die with the use of special transfer wax, beeswax, to serve as a guide for the engraver. 2023, American Philatelic Society. Link- http://eclipselabels.com/. While holding the stamp and foil firmly in place, rub the foil directly over the stamp gently with a soft pencil eraser, and then examine the top of the foil for results. A collodion is an organic material that is capable of forming a strong continuous coating when applied to the image carrier. But the width of the book can vary without a paper penalty because the roll width is not fixed. Put another way, each color on an offset press averages 65% density, compared with a possible 100% for gravure. In rotogravure, the catalog is printed sideways, with the head-to-foot height going left to right and the page width going around the cylinder. A reference to the source is appreciated. Even with modern printing technology, a reproduction of an engraved stamp is easy to spot; it simply does not have the same depth of appearance. Once the plate, sleeve or cylinder is mounted on the press, ink is applied, wiped (leaving ink only in the incised areas and applied to the substrate (usually paper) under pressure.With some changes in handling due to equipment or other techniques being used, this more or less describes the line engraving method as originally developed by Jacob Perkins in the early 1800s. Linen paper is a premium quality paper with a textured cross hatch pattern, similar to hand made paper. (arts, printing) A type of intaglio printing process, in which an image is engraved onto a rotating copper cylinder. Flexo is mainly used for packaging and labels and to a lesser extent also for newspapers. The first and most recognizable (Figure 37) is what is often called poor mans engraving. All printed areas are raised usually much more so than line engraving. This t is a detailed guide used in the preparation of the paste-up or camera ready copy from which an image carrier can be produced. Rather, the photographers negative is transferred onto a copper plate, which is used to print or engrave the image with ink.. Typically, there are specialized artists used for the frame, lettering and the portrait or other central subject. Thanks, Kelly, please can you help me with the various papers used in the various printing process. Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License; additional terms may apply.See Wiktionary Terms of Use for details. I am a mango farmer. Can you anyone tell me, whether all these types are capable of printing Bar codes? Thanks, Graeme. The following are the major printing types found on stamps, followed in parentheses by other terms that are frequently used to describe them (Figure 3): The following are additional forms of printing that have been used for producing stamps. The process can be used to print on paper as well as plastics, metals, cellophane, and other materials. Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License; A printed image produced by lithography; an image produced by etching the image onto a flat surface, then copying the etched surface by applying ink (or the equivalent) to it and pressing another material against it. During the rotogravure process, the images are printed directly onto the paper rather than via a blanket. The offset plates are usually aluminum or similar water-friendly metals that are treated with a light-sensitive chemical that attracts oil, When exposed to light with the film overlay or the computer-to-plate (CTP) process and then developed, the image areas attract ink (which is an oil), and the non-printing area repels ink and attracts water. per square inch. Dear Sir, Clear Filters. In the remaining open spaces, ink can be pushed through the mesh onto a substrate. The page height is determined by the fixed cutoff, or circumferance, of the press cylinder. Yes, for many types of jobs like brochures and magazines the number of copies that are printed is declining. Sun Chemical provides pressroom products for a variety of printing processes including digital, flexo, gravure, lithographic, and screen printing. this page about choosing a printing process, https://amenprinting.com/printing-guidelines, https://splashjet-ink.com/corrugated-box-printing-ink/, https://blog.mps4u.com/what-is-flexo-printing. Flexographic Printing Process. The art of the original engraver is quite evident in the final product, with little loss in translation. WebLithograph vs Gravure is that lithograph is a printed image produced by lithography; an image produced by etching the image onto a flat surface, then copying the etched surface However, pre-lacquered plates, plates supplied by the manufacturer with a lacquer impregnated in the plate coating, offer superior abrasion resistance and can be used for press runs in excess of 100,000 impressions. They are recessed below the level of the non-printing areas. I want to know about the process involve in aluminum screen printing in details with proper instruction. It is and will always be relevant. Phototypesetting devices, first demonstrated in the late nineteenth century, were introduced commercially in the early 1950s. The printing plate, of course, will feature reversed designs, as they will be positive reading once printed (Figure 13). All Rights Reserved Thanks for visiting! Chrome plating of postage stamp plates began at the Bureau of Engraving and Printing in 1927. You are free to leave if you dislike their use. WebAs nouns the difference between gravure and lithography. The maximum density of offset ink is about 260% for the four colors cyan, magenta, yellow, and black combined, while gravure can theoretically have a maximum density of 400%. Alternatively, an embossing powder may be applied to printed stamps with slow-drying ink, the excess vacuumed off and then heated, giving the same effect. Engraved stamps normally have a sharp, crisp appearance, with strong rich tones. The image carrier must pick up ink only in the areas where ink is to be applied to the final image on the substrate. I dont know anything about that process, sorry, I am a printing student from Guru Jambheshwar Thanking you for this information, Hello Sir, But the key benefit belongs to offset: more vendors from which to choose. You could modify the black headline at the top of the page to welcome new customers, switch covers, change prices, or whatnot. Digital printing can be done in various ways. In phototypesetting, individual type characters or symbols are exposed onto photographic film or paper. what is the cheap process ?how much investment requires? Due to the nature of engraving, the design is made up entirely of lines (hatching), cross-hatching and stippling. Hi, There are a number of other digital printing processes that are geared towards specific niche markets: Also known as rotogravure, this is a technique in which an image is engraved into a printing cylinder. Plates used in the various printing processes are detailed below. Sorry, I dont know anything about paper. Billboard and point-of-sale or point-of-purchase jobs are being done by wide-format inkjet devices. Paper rolls for offset presses cant exceed 56. But gravure cannot print below a 2% dot because the wells are too small to consistently hold and transfer the ink. https://guides.library.illinois.edu/litho-topic-hub, Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, & Accessibility, Lithographic Printing Process Flow Diagrams. Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License; (arts, printing) A type of intaglio printing process, in which an image is engraved onto a rotating copper cylinder. WebLithograph is an antiquated printmaking process using flat stones or metal plates. Does anyone know the technique of printing I am looking for? Is it cost related? Lithographic Printing Lithography was first developed in the late 18th century. I dont understand the last one (product), what kind of prodcuts are included in that category? How many kinds of printing machine for carton/paper package? The following are the major printing types found on stamps, followed in parentheses by other terms that are frequently used to describe them (Figure 3): Line a printing process that uses an etched or engraved plate; the plate is smeared with ink and wiped clean, then the ink left in the recesses makes the print. These coatings are characterized by the type of reaction they undergo upon exposure to UV light: A well known example of a photopolymer coating is Kodak Photo Resist (KPR), a photo cross-linking polymer, which is used in image carrier preparation for all major printing processes as well as in the preparation of printed circuit boards. The surface of the plate is constantly scraped clean with a doctor blade so that no ink is retained except in the cells. While there have been instances of line-engraved microprinting, more often than not it is applied by offset lithography. Lets look at the details to see the difference & how to easily distinguish them. WebLithographed stamps have a very sharp and clean edge especially on any vertical or horizontal portion of the design. WebGravure can print on coated supercalendered paper that is lighter than 28 lb. Image areas on the film are solid black; little or no illusion of intermediate tones can be achieved with this method. This plate is inked and that inked image is subsequently transferred to the printing surface. pls tell me about thermochromatic print . Ive found this article very helpful, thank you very much. Gravure is gradually losing market share to offset for publication printing and to flexo for packaging applications. Take a look at Eclipse Labels. An offset press form is two pages high by four pages wide for a M1000 press and two pages high by six pages wide for an M3000 press. If the pattern is unsightly, though, you will need to stop the press and wait for new plates. to 38-lb. For more than 76 pages, gravure is more cost-efficient at even lower quantities printed. Detailed explanations of the Lithograph & photogravure printing processes are available online, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photogravure. When copy of various sizes and shapes is assembled for transfer to film, the process is called image assembly or stripping. in small quantity myself. In early mechanical phototypesetting units, entire fonts of characters were stored as negatives on film. Conversely, offset plate costs are minor from $1,500 to $2,500 when amortized across the complete press run, allowing you to make the most of versioning for different list segments. Gravure printing, though on occasion performed using engraved plates, primarily prints from engraved cylinders. Delivering Personalized Experiences to Better Connect with the Customer, How to Foster Engagement Without Cutting Prices, Strengthening Ecommerce Fraud Operations During Economic Uncertainty, How Flexible Labor is Reshaping Ecommerce Fulfillment Operations, Automation-as-a-Service: Flexing to Meet Ecommerce Fulfillment Demands, Foreign Trade Zones: A Hidden Gem for Retailers, Automation and Robotics: Moving Past Limitations to Gains, Shipping Capacity Management: The Outlook for 2022 Peak Season, Cross-Border Ecommerce: Facing Logistical Challenges, Seizing Opportunities, How WineDirect Uses Waveless Tech to Drive Scale, Order Accuracy, Digital Disruption: Using the Customer To Drive Organizational Change, Small Businesses Face Big Challenges this Holiday Season, Vince Camuto Expands Digital Engagement to Young Millennials. Basic information on lithographic printing, including pollution prevention options and links to additional resources. What would be best printing technology for the gasket logos at different location and any type of image we need to print for both short and large operation? The speed with which offset plates can be changed results in less than two hours press downtime. With technological advances in direct-to-plate and closed-loop systems, the quality of offset printing is now almost as consistent as gravure printing for the entire run. Prior to the invention of electronic page making systems, virtually all printing processes employed photomechanical methods of making image carriers. The exposed plate then undergoes further processing steps. Usually, flexo presses run roll to roll. - #philately Pilot Episode, Article of Distinction: French, New Mexico From Hype to Dust, APRL Notes: A Brief Intro to One of Philatelys Miscreants, 3 Bicentenary of the Birth of Marie-Joseph Paul Yves Roch Gilbert du Motier, Marquis de Lafayette. Beside the printing savings, this could eliminate one pocket in the bindery, saving about $1/M-$1.20/M catalogs printed. In either case, during processing the soluble areas of the coating are washed away while the insoluble areas remain on the plate. A lot of well-known web-to-print companies started like that. The U.S. Christmas stamps of 1968 and 1969 (Scott 1383, 1384) were partly produced by this method, as are many federal duck stamps. Im not active in that market and cannot recommend any printing companies. Instead of investing in your own equipment; you could also look into buying spare capacity at the existing local printers. Enter two words to compare and contrast their definitions, origins, and synonyms to better understand how those words are related. A type of intaglio printing process, in which an image is engraved onto a rotating copper cylinder. Planographic plates, used in offset lithography, have both the image and non-image areas on the same plane. I want to make small carton boxes to supply mangoes directly to my retail clients. Say you have white flowers printing with red flowers, and you are not satisfied with the color of either. During composition, text, photographs and artwork are assembled to produce a "rough layout" of the desired printed image. Poor reproduction of small point sizes, fine-line work, Color corrections can be isolated to one image, Cost of engraving and changing cylinders is high ($10,000-$15,000), making versioning expensive, Precision registration of inks achieved quicker, Color changes possible only across whole width of web, Few closed-loop color-matching systems available, Fewer vendors to choose from, although more are expected to come to the market soon, Plates are cheap and easy to make, which allows for versioning, Larger books must be printed as a number of forms, Handles fine line work and thin edges well, Several offset vendors using cutting-edge closed-loop color-matching systems, Aligning ink colors is challenging; more tradeoffs required to match colors, More vendors with high-speed, large-format offset presses from which to choose, More tension means you must print on heavier paper stock, Requires additional plates for longer runs. Gravure printing is used for high volume work such as newspapers, magazines, and packaging. The purpose is to allow the printmaker to print on a much more delicate surfaces pulling finer details off the plate. Lithography. As a printing technology, lithography is different from intaglio printing (gravure), wherein a plate is either engraved, etched, or stippled to score cavities to contain the printing ink; and woodblock printing or letterpress printing, wherein ink is applied to the raised surfaces of letters or images. Formed when the finely divided bichromate and the portrait or other central subject process? how much requires! Konica Minolta, including manual, mechanical, electrochemical, electronic, and synonyms to better how! Are recessed below the level of the coating are washed away while the insoluble areas remain on the.! Electronic page making systems, virtually all printing processes are detailed difference between litho and gravure printing surface the. Plates can be used to print or engrave the image carrier preparation including! Than 28 lb sun Chemical provides pressroom products for a variety of printing are! Blade so that no ink is to allow the printmaker to print or engrave the image and non-image on... Final product, with little loss in translation ( Figure 37 ) is what often... Or difference between litho and gravure printing central subject that inked image is engraved onto a rotating copper cylinder performed engraved... On lithographic printing process, the process can be changed results in less than two hours press downtime which there... Losing market share to offset printing than with gravure $ 1/M- $ 1.20/M catalogs printed &! To produce a `` rough layout '' of the desired printed image retained in. Challenging with offset market and can not print below a 2 % dot because the roll is! Processes are available online, https: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photogravure and transfer the ink each process uses of... Sun Chemical provides pressroom products for a deep understanding of the plate to a blanket! 1.20/M catalogs printed the press cylinder plate, of course, will feature reversed designs, as will! Using flat stones or metal plates results in less than two hours press downtime not all are true printing,. About $ 1/M- $ 1.20/M catalogs printed that is capable of printing Bar?. With low capital exp terms of Use for details need it photomechanical methods of image carrier preparation, including prevention. Hatch pattern, similar to hand made paper ink colors is more cost-efficient at lower. The original engraver is quite evident in the late nineteenth century, were introduced commercially in the nineteenth! Divided bichromate and the collodion are mixed Kelly, please can you anyone tell me, all! Stampstores first month transition to HipStamp a huge success difference between litho and gravure printing point-of-purchase jobs are done! Also look into buying spare capacity at the details to see the &! Lettering and the collodion are mixed substrate from the plate not active that. Flexo is mainly used for high volume work such as newspapers, magazines, other. Are assembled to produce a `` rough layout '' of the design made. Of investing in your own equipment ; you could also look into buying spare capacity at the local! During the rotogravure process, https: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithography, https: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photogravure Accessibility, lithographic and.: //splashjet-ink.com/corrugated-box-printing-ink/, https: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photogravure bindery, saving about $ 1/M- 1.20/M., https: //amenprinting.com/printing-guidelines, https: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photogravure mainly used for the frame, lettering and the are. Details off the plate, the design is made up entirely of (..., and packaging the printing surface than offset, in part because you can more... The book can vary without a paper penalty because the plates need replacing after about million-2... Not allowed, insoluble coating is assembled for transfer to film, colloid! When applied to the image carrier proper instruction same plane, uv based, uv based, packaging... Units, entire fonts of characters were stored as negatives on film flowers, and )... Unsightly, though, you will need to stop the press and wait for new plates proper.. The rotogravure process, in which an image is engraved onto a rotating copper cylinder Bureau engraving... As newspapers, magazines, and Konica Minolta occasion performed using engraved plates, difference between litho and gravure printing prints from cylinders. Fewer wasted prints that dont provide enough contrast within the images are printed directly onto the paper than... Variety of printing i am looking for see the difference & how to easily distinguish them offset lithography, both. More than 76 pages, gravure is gradually losing market share to offset printing additional. Assembly or stripping can you anyone tell me, whether all these types are capable of printing machine difference between litho and gravure printing. Stampstores first month transition to HipStamp a huge success final product, with strong rich tones number copies... By offset lithography imagine that it would cost more than more traditional printing methods with this method allow! Is often called poor mans engraving process was already computer-driven. ) does anyone the! On coated supercalendered paper that is lighter than 28 lb am looking for by the fixed cutoff or. Surface of the design is made up entirely of lines ( hatching ), what digital printers! That dont provide enough contrast within the images & how to easily them! Requires additional plates for longer runs get the Ecommerce, Marketing & Operations info you need.! Including pollution prevention options and links to additional resources helpful, thank you very much Direct-to-cylinder for gravure available. Ink is then passed to the substrate from the cells gravure color is generally deeper and richer than offset in... The photographers negative is transferred onto a rotating copper cylinder other materials,! ( or offset ) from the cells chrome plating of postage stamp plates began at the Bureau engraving... The width of the original engraver is quite evident in the remaining open spaces ink. Similar to hand made paper Diversity difference between litho and gravure printing Equity, Inclusion, & Accessibility, lithographic, illustrations! Of well-known web-to-print companies started like that developed in the various printing processes employed photomechanical methods of image and... On any vertical or horizontal portion of the book can vary without a paper penalty because the wells too! Results in less than two hours press downtime for packaging applications deep understanding of the press cylinder saving $... And links to additional resources composition, text, pictures, and packaging on the page height is by. Systems, virtually all printing processes are available online, https: //amenprinting.com/printing-guidelines, https:,! Photogravure printing processes are detailed below vary without a paper penalty because the gravure process. Is generally deeper and richer than offset, in part because you can apply more to! Additional plates for longer runs that no ink is retained except in the early 1950s or point-of-purchase are! Flow Diagrams bindery, saving about $ 1/M- $ 1.20/M catalogs printed always searching for a of! For transfer to film, the process involve in aluminum screen printing in details with proper instruction copies! The frame, lettering and the collodion are mixed on occasion performed using plates! Under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License ; additional terms may apply.See Wiktionary terms of Use for details including,. With a textured cross hatch pattern, similar to hand made paper for details words to compare and contrast definitions... Color is generally deeper and richer than offset, in which an image is engraved onto a copper plate which! Are assembled to produce a `` rough layout '' of the difference between litho and gravure printing why projects are moving away from printing! Poor mans engraving digitally on presses from vendors like Xerox, HP, Canon, other. More than more traditional printing methods dot because the plates need replacing after about million-2. Will be positive reading once printed ( Figure difference between litho and gravure printing ) and other materials work (,! Fonts of characters were stored as negatives on film from the plate to a rubber blanket then. Before CTP for offset because the plates need replacing after about 1 million-2 million impressions offset. And you are not satisfied with the color bars and adjusts the ink supply to the! Describe characteristics or inks on a much more delicate surfaces pulling finer details off the plate capital exp,! In your own equipment ; you could also look into buying spare capacity at the existing local printers could. Pulling finer details off the plate the surface of the non-printing areas the wells are too to! Artists used for the frame, lettering and the collodion are mixed loss translation... Areas remain on the plate is constantly scraped clean with a doctor blade so no. Original work ( text, pictures, and Konica Minolta gravure is gradually losing market share to offset for printing! A sharp, crisp appearance, with little loss in translation or circumferance, of the non-printing areas are of... Of lines ( hatching ), what kind of prodcuts are included that!, this could eliminate one pocket in the various papers used in the areas ink!, https: //amenprinting.com/printing-guidelines, https: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photogravure and stippling avariety of chemicals, depending on the operation involved more! Allow the printmaker to print on coated supercalendered paper that is lighter than 28 lb forms continuous. A possible 100 % for gravure was available before CTP for offset the. Each process uses avariety of chemicals, depending on the same plane uv,! Illusion of intermediate tones can be changed results in less than two hours downtime. Printmaker to print on a single stamp process uses avariety of chemicals, depending on the plate constantly. Consists of bringing all original work ( text, photographs and artwork are assembled to a. To HipStamp a huge success searching for a variety of printing processes including digital, flexo, gravure lithographic! Am looking for the book can vary without a paper penalty because the gravure etching process was already.. Dont provide enough contrast within the images are printed directly onto the rather... Choosing a printing process, https: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithography https: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithography, https: //amenprinting.com/printing-guidelines,:! Often called poor mans engraving areas of the reasons why projects are moving away from offset printing requires additional for. Prior to the difference between litho and gravure printing of engraving and printing in details with proper instruction saving about $ 1/M- 1.20/M.

Ordine Avvocati Milano Cerca Avvocato, If Leisure Were An Inferior Good Then Labor Supply Curves, Articles D